How to Spot and Elevate Underutilized Talent in Your Company

Every workplace has its quiet strengths—the folks who don’t always take center stage but have the capacity to drive massive change. These are the underutilized employees, often overlooked not out of malice but because managers are juggling a hundred other things. Still, ignoring their potential can slowly drain your team’s energy, innovation, and morale. As a leader, it’s on you to spot those dormant engines and help them shift into high gear. It’s not just about performance reviews and KPIs—it’s about real engagement, trust, and intention. Once you start looking through the right lens, what you find might just change the entire direction of your business.

Look Beyond the Obvious

That one employee who never misses a deadline but rarely speaks up in meetings? You might assume they’re just quiet or disengaged. More likely, they haven’t been asked the right questions—or given the right opportunity. People don’t raise their hands if they think no one’s paying attention. Start by noticing patterns in work ethic, creative input, and even casual conversations. If someone consistently delivers without being recognized, they might already be doing more than you know. Your job is to peel back the layers and learn what motivates them beyond their current role.

Audit Responsibilities, Not Just Results

Too often, managers zero in on metrics without understanding the human behind the numbers. It’s easy to assume someone’s maxed out just because they’re meeting expectations. But expectations and capacity aren’t the same thing. Look at who’s coasting on autopilot—who’s finishing their work early, volunteering for side tasks, or showing interest in areas beyond their job description. A responsibility audit lets you ask the right questions: What are they actually doing day to day? Where’s the extra room they haven’t been challenged in yet? Small shifts here can lead to huge leaps later.

Revive One-on-One Conversations

Most one-on-ones are transactional—updates, deadlines, feedback loops. But if you really want to understand where someone’s being underused, you have to dig deeper. Ask open-ended questions that invite reflection: What part of your job do you wish you could spend more time on? What’s something you’ve always wanted to try here but haven’t had the chance? You’ll be surprised how often people reveal goals, skills, and frustrations you never expected. A meaningful one-on-one is less about ticking boxes and more about listening with purpose.

Develop Training Materials

Building solid training materials is key when you’re teaching employees something new—whether it’s a process change, a technical skill, or onboarding a new system. You want the content to be clear, practical, and accessible so that people can reference it long after the session ends. Using visuals, real-world examples, and simple language helps make the information stick. Once you’ve created your materials, saving them as PDFs ensures they’re easy to share and maintain consistent formatting across devices. This resource explains how you can convert, compress, edit, rotate, and reorder PDFs to keep everything clean and organized. 

Create Shadowing and Cross-Training Opportunities

It’s hard to unlock someone’s hidden talents if they never step outside their usual lane. Cross-training isn’t just a contingency plan—it’s a window into undiscovered value. Let team members shadow others in different departments for a day or even just a few hours. You might find that your junior analyst has a mind for UX, or that your marketing assistant thrives when working with numbers. Shadowing breaks routine and invites people to reimagine where they fit within the company. It also builds empathy and a deeper understanding of how the whole machine works.

Use Internal Project Pitches as Talent Spotlights

Most companies save pitch moments for leadership or external vendors. Flip that script. Let your employees pitch ideas for small internal projects or process improvements. It gives them a low-risk way to flex creative muscles and show leadership potential. More importantly, it shows you who’s thinking outside their job title. When someone steps up with a thoughtful proposal, you’re getting a peek at where their untapped drive really lives. It’s not just about who speaks loudest—it’s about who shows up with clarity and courage.

Reward Initiative, Not Just Execution

It’s easy to reward the people who get things done, but what about those who try something new, even if it doesn’t pan out perfectly? If you only recognize flawless execution, you’ll unintentionally discourage creativity. People will stick to what’s safe because that’s what gets noticed. Instead, carve out space to celebrate risk-takers—the ones who ask “why not” and take on challenges outside their lane. These employees often have underused strategic thinking skills or leadership instincts that just need a little air. A team that knows you reward initiative will surface more of its hidden players over time.

Break the Mold of Traditional Roles

Job descriptions are guidelines, not shackles. Some of the best contributions can come from letting employees stretch beyond what they were technically hired to do. Give people the freedom to experiment with other areas, whether it’s helping on a campaign, contributing to a product idea, or mentoring a peer. You’re not tossing structure out the window—you’re making room for people to grow into roles the company doesn’t even know it needs yet. Talent doesn’t evolve in a vacuum; it grows in friction, freedom, and collaboration. The more flexible the sandbox, the more innovation you’ll invite.

Encourage Peer Recognition

Managers don’t see everything. In fact, some of the most telling examples of underutilized brilliance happen away from your eyes—peer help, quiet leadership, creative fixes in high-pressure moments. Set up a space for employees to recognize each other’s contributions, either informally or through structured shoutouts. When peers call attention to each other’s work, you get a fuller picture of who’s making an impact. It also builds culture from the ground up. You’re not just finding hidden talent—you’re building trust and transparency that helps it rise naturally.

Let Feedback Flow Upward

Leaders don’t always invite feedback because, well, it’s uncomfortable. But if you want your team to grow, you have to be willing to grow too. Underutilized employees often hold a mirror to company blind spots—they see broken systems, outdated tools, or cultural issues that leadership has tuned out. Give them ways to safely share those insights. Anonymous suggestion boxes are fine, but nothing beats a culture where upward feedback is part of the rhythm. When people know they can speak truth to power, they stop hiding their intelligence and start leaning into it.

Track Hidden Wins, Not Just Headlines

Everyone loves a splashy win—a big sale, a successful launch, a killer marketing campaign. But the quiet contributions matter too: the spreadsheet that saved the team hours, the back-end fix no one noticed but everyone benefited from, the steady hand during a chaotic stretch. Make a habit of spotlighting these less glamorous but deeply valuable wins. They often come from people whose talents aren’t flashy but foundational. By tracking and recognizing these moments, you’re telling your team that all forms of excellence count—and you’re creating a culture that sees the full spectrum of contribution.

Connect People to the “Why”

Sometimes employees aren’t underutilized because of lack of opportunity—they’re disengaged because the work feels disconnected from purpose. If someone doesn’t understand why their role matters, they’ll never bring their full energy to it. Help your team see how their efforts ladder up to the bigger mission. Show them the ripple effect of their work on customers, colleagues, or the company’s direction. When someone sees how their piece fits the whole, they tend to step up, stretch out, and dig deeper. Meaning fuels momentum—and you’re the one who helps light the fuse.

You don’t have to overhaul your org chart or create a dozen new positions to unlock the potential that’s already sitting in your company. You just have to get intentional about looking—and listening. The people you think of as “steady” or “supporting” might be sitting on ideas, skills, and leadership instincts that could reshape your business. They’re not waiting for permission; they’re waiting for attention. Give it to them. And when you do, don’t be surprised if your quietest players turn out to be your most valuable ones.

Discover the transformative insights of leadership, marketing, and communication with internationally recognized speaker Jamie Turner. Learn more and elevate your next event!